My social media feeds have been flooded with “manifesting” content lately. Everywhere. Is manifestation or the Law of Attraction a sin for Christians?
Yes. Manifesting, the way it’s taught online, is a sin. It puts you in God’s seat and treats the universe like a vending machine that answers to your thoughts. God is a Father who answers prayer.
Most of what’s flooding your feed is New Thought from the 1800s with new branding. The tell is it only ever asks ‘do I believe hard enough?’ Whether it’s God’s will doesn’t come up at all. Jesus in Gethsemane prayed ‘not my will but yours.’
Manifesting in the Law of Attraction sense is sinful. It gives our thoughts and words a spiritual power Scripture never says they have, and it implies people brought on their own illness or grief by thinking negatively.
Setting goals or keeping a gratitude journal is fine though.
I tried the affirmations. I was trying to talk a better version of myself into existence one ‘I am’ line at a time, and God had dropped out of the picture.
I think manifesting (the Law of Attraction version at least) is a sin for Christians, it makes your own words the source of your identity.
Sorry if this is slightly off track, but the point about blaming people for their own illness hit home after my aunt’s cancer diagnosis.
That second part about blaming people for their own illness is what bugs me most, since it sounds exactly like Job’s friends lecturing him.
I started one a few years ago. After a while it turned into a list of things I wanted to ‘attract’ and the tone went from thankfulness to bargaining. Is the practice itself harmless, or does it all depend on who the gratitude is directed toward?
Thankfulness needs someone to thank. A journal that says ‘I’m grateful for’ but never names the recipient tends to drift toward the universe by default.
Simple test, whether the page looks back at what He has already given or only forward at what you hope to get.
Most of those manifesting techniques come from Neville Goddard, the law of assumption, scripting, visualizing as you fall asleep. He quoted the Bible constantly but taught that God is your own imagination and your awareness is the I AM from Exodus, so it’s hard to treat as harmless self-help with some Christian words sprinkled in.
Lamentations 3:37, “Who can speak and have it happen if the Lord has not decreed it?” Take what you were hoping for and bring it to God instead.
A lot of those videos throw around science-y words like frequency and vibration to sound legit, but none of it can be tested or shown to work. It’s a separate question whether it’s a sin, but the Law of Attraction uses the word law to make it sound official.
Pseudoscience with a Bible verse slapped on, I’d steer clear. People like to quote Mark 11:24 to make manifesting sound biblical but that verse is about asking God for things in prayer.
I test manifesting the same way I test anything else, with two questions: is Jesus part of it, and is the point to glorify God? If the answer to either one is no, it’s sin.
Most of the manifesting content I’ve seen fails both.
Manifesting borrows something prayer already has, that moment where you stop gripping a problem, hand it over to God and trust him with it. That’s why it hooks so many people.
It’s an old idea that’s been repackaged a bunch of times and the surrender part is usually the first thing to get lost.
A lot of the appeal seems to be that it makes you feel like you’ve finally got a handle on your life, and that feeling of control is the hook.
If something other than God is giving you that, it’s hard to say you’re seeking Him with your whole heart.
God put those desires in us in the first place, you could argue, and gave us the means to reach them. Believing big is fine Christian or not.
Say I’m obsessed with surfing, I check the surf report every morning and drag myself out of bed at 5am to get to the beach. Wanting it shaped my choices and got me in the water and that’s most of what people call ‘manifesting’.
The Law of Attraction gives the credit to some cosmic force. The bigger question is what you’re pouring all that wanting into, Matthew 6:21: ‘For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.’
I’d saved half her posts before I noticed I’d stopped praying in the mornings. This account had beige candle-and-journal photos and soft voiceovers about ‘aligning with your highest self’, and I was scripting my ‘dream life’ in a notebook instead.
The most dangerous lies usually look beautiful.
Next time a manifesting video pops up, ask what it tells you to do when the dream doesn’t happen. ‘Believe in yourself and your dreams will come true’ is basically a Disney movie plot and real life doesn’t follow the script.
I wouldn’t call it a sin though, there’s some truth buried in there.
I stopped chasing my own vision board. Now I try to seek his kingdom first and let him make me into who he wants me to be.
It’s turned out way better than anything I could’ve planned on my own.
Proverbs 3:5-6 says, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding.”
Jeremiah 17:5-8 goes further. It says the person who trusts in man and makes flesh his strength is like a shrub in the desert, while the one who trusts the Lord is like a tree planted by water.
So yes, relying on some vague force to push your life forward is a sin, and it’s pretty close to witchcraft. We’re supposed to put our weight on God, who loves us.