Why do some Christians think wearing a cross is wrong? Not all, obviously. But enough that I’ve been told I shouldn’t do it.
Most of the pushback comes from the second commandment. People worry about turning a symbol into an idol or good luck charm, and some traditions avoid religious imagery because the early church didn’t wear crosses, it came later from Roman culture.
I grew up in a church like that. I wore one anyway for years. It reminded me who I belonged to whenever I caught it in the mirror. If someone tells you it’s wrong, ask them where scripture says so. Romans 14 puts this thing in the category of personal conscience.
The New Testament never says Christians can’t wear a cross. Some churches discourage jewelry in general and read 1 Timothy 2:9-10 and 1 Peter 3:3-4 as calling for plain dress without gold or ornaments.
Others are bothered by wearing an instrument of execution as decoration.
Plenty of people wear one as a reminder or out of gratitude, though.
I’ve worn a small one. Easy to feel covered by it on a day when my conduct didn’t match, and the people who told me not to were thinking about what Jesus asked for, the daily cost of following him.
Not ready to call every cross necklace a sin though.
Mine catches my eye during stressful workdays
and pulls me back to gratitude.
I wear my tiny cross as a reminder:blush: and it makes me feel all happy and grateful inside, just like you said.
The execution angle is the whole point of wearing it. Paul boasted in the cross in Galatians 6:14 and the early believers used the word for the thing that killed Jesus without any issue.
1 Timothy and 1 Peter are harder. But the churches that cite them apply them to necklaces, not to a nice suit or a new truck in the parking lot.
Edit: I think the plain dress folks are right to take those verses seriously.
Actual idolatry isn’t a matter of personal conscience for Paul (1 Corinthians 10:14). A general prohibition can cover something without naming it.
Your distinction between a reminder of belonging to Christ and a good luck charm is the stronger argument though. When you use a symbol to remember Christ your trust is still in Christ.
Luke 9:23, take up your cross daily. Wearing one around your neck doesn’t cover that.
Glad you stopped short of calling every necklace sinful though. A cross can still be a call to repentance.
There’s some graffiti in Rome, probably from the second or third century, showing a man saluting a crucified figure with a donkey’s head. The caption says ‘Alexamenos worships his god.’ It was a joke. That’s what the cross meant to people, and Paul says as much in 1 Corinthians 1:23: ‘a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles.’
When I wear one, I’m owning what the world laughed at. Jesus endured it ‘for the joy that was set before him’ and he sits at the right hand now.
Mine’s just a personal preference, I’m one of those people who won’t wear a cross and I still think you’re fine wearing yours. I’d never expect anyone else to follow it.
If whoever told you that was like me they probably forgot to say the ‘for me’ part out loud.
Fine with people wearing one. It bothers me when people talk about the actual piece of metal on the chain like it protects you… at that point it’s basically an amulet shaped like a Christian symbol, and people end up trusting the metal instead of the one the cross points to.
Once you put one on, strangers see you as a Christian right away. If what you say and believe doesn’t match that, it can give people the wrong idea about the faith. I think that responsibility is what they’re worried about.
Depends who told you. If it was a Jehovah’s Witness, that’s a whole different objection.
They teach that Jesus died on a single upright torture stake, so to them the cross is a pagan symbol that got tacked on later. Mainstream Christians who object to the cross itself are a small group.
Sorry you’ve been made to feel like you’re doing something wrong. Most believers (and I really do mean most) can tell the difference between a cross worn as a sign of faith and one that’s just jewelry.
Settle before God whether wearing that cross is harmless or whether it’s doing you some harm. Nobody bows down to jewelry by accident, and the people warning you know that. Idolatry can take root without any actual worship, though.
Romans 14 is worth reading if the people criticizing your necklace are from your own church. You’re free to wear it, but maybe tuck it under your shirt when the no-jewelry folks are around.
