Do Animals Have Souls According to the Bible?

General
1

Do dogs have souls? I think God could have a place for them.

A lot of people here hold that only humans were given eternal spirits, and I get the theology behind it. I used to agree without really thinking about it, but I lost a pet recently so I was sitting with the thought for a bit.

When you live with an animal day after day, you see loyalty, grief, something that looks so much like love that calling it “just instinct” is leaving something out of it. Anyone who has had a pet knows what I’m talking about. Maybe something connected to the Creator, even if in a small way.

“Who knows the spirit of the sons of men, which goes upward, and the spirit of the animal, which goes down to the earth?” Ecclesiastes 3:21

I have read this verse probably a dozen times now and it still reads more like an open question to me than a definitive answer. Not sure if that is just wishful thinking but scripture does have a question mark there. I don’t think the Bible gives us a plain, direct statement on what happens to animals after death. It just… doesn’t, which leaves room. Maybe too much room for some people, but I would rather sit with the uncertainty than pretend it’s settled.

If He made them with the ability to bond with us the way they do (and anyone who’s grieved a pet knows exactly what I mean), then the idea that He might have something for them beyond this life doesn’t feel like a stretch.

What does everyone else think? Do dogs have a soul? Do they go to heaven or does God discard them?

13 Likes
2

Your Prayer Delivered to the Holy Land

You don’t have to pray alone. Have your prayer submitted to the Holy Land as well as churches, monasteries, and prayer groups worldwide who will lift your intentions to God and pray on your behalf.

From the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem to sacred sites across the globe, your prayer will be shared and remembered.

Submit your prayer here.

3

First of all, sorry about your pet. That grief is real. :pleading_face:

So here’s what I know. The Hebrew word ‘nephesh’, the one we translate as ‘soul’, is actually used for animals and humans in Genesis. In Genesis 2:7, man is called a ‘living soul’ - nephesh chayyah. In Genesis 1:21 and 1:24, animals are called ‘living creatures.’ Same Hebrew phrase. Nephesh chayyah both times.

The KJV translators chose to use ‘soul’ for humans and ‘creature’ for animals, but in the original text, the word is the same. If I’m getting this right, nephesh appears more than 700 times in the Old Testament and is translated into more than 20 English words, depending on context.

So the ‘animals don’t have souls’ idea is partly a translation choice. When your dog mourns, protects you, or loses its mind with joy when you walk in the door, to me, that’s nephesh.

Now, there might be a difference between soul and spirit, though. Look into the trichotomous view.

It’s basically about “body, soul, spirit” for humans, vs. just “body” and a basic “soul” for animals. The idea is that some animals have nephesh (the seat of mind, will, emotion), but not the same kind of spirit - ruach - that connects humans to God.

But even that is debated, you know? Because Ecclesiastes 3:19 says humans and animals “all have the same breath,” and the word there is ruach (Spirit).

1 Like
4

Your Ecclesiastes quote is a good one. But definitely reads as an open question.

I think the strongest passage for what you’re getting at is Romans 8.

Paul says the whole creation is groaning together, waiting for liberation from its “bondage to decay,” and that it will be brought into “the glorious freedom of the children of God” (Romans 8:19-22). He uses the word “creation,” not “human.”

We know Animals didn’t sin. They got caught up in the curse through no fault of their own. So if creation itself gets delivered, that has to include the animal kingdom in some way.

I do like Randy Alcorn’s logic. He believes animals will be part of the renewed creation.

He refers to Romans 8, too, and the logic is pretty straightforward: “If God plans to make all things new rather than scrap everything, and if animals were part of the original ‘very good’ creation, then a restored earth would naturally include them.” I like that.

Another one to read is Isaiah 11:6: “The wolf dwelling with the lamb, the leopard lying down with the goat.”

And then there’s Revelation 5:13: “every creature in heaven and on earth and under the earth praising God.” It says “every creature.”

I won’t pretend scripture gives a definitive ‘your specific dog will be waiting for you.’ It doesn’t. But the biblical stories tell us animals are included in what God is making new.

1 Like
5

Grieving a pet is hard. I’ve been there. And I know exactly what you mean about seeing something deeper than instinct in them.

C.S. Lewis said that scripture is silent on specifics. He called his ideas a ‘supposal’ - basically an informed guess. But he also said that silence doesn’t mean no. So if animals were immortal, that’s exactly the kind of thing God might not reveal to us. He even talked about how human immortality was a concept in Jewish thought.

I read in The Problem of Pain that tame animals (basically pets) are the most ‘natural’ animals because they live under the loving dominion of a human master. And through that relationship, they develop something like real selfhood.

‘As we are raised in Christ, so at least some animals are raised in us. Not existing independently in the afterlife, but as part of a household, part of that bond with their human.’ C.S. Lewis.

Also, in The Great Divorce, a redeemed woman is pictured in heaven, surrounded by animals that had known her love, with the life she had in Christ flowing over into them. Beautiful image.

My take is that God made animals with the ability to love us and to be loved by us. I don’t think it’s a stretch to hope that our animals are part of God’s restoring plan.

Not as a guarantee. But as a real hope grounded in who God is.

6

Look your pet in the eye sometimes. Really look. They know what you’re feeling, and they react to your emotional state the same way another person would.

They do it because they genuinely understand, not out of instinct or training.

I have watched animals cry. Whether from physical pain or emotional hurt, the response is real.

And I have seen them make actual decisions. My dog weighs the situation, reads the room, and figures out what’s appropriate. This is beyond survival instinct.

The Bible might not spell it out directly, but there are passages saying God gave every living being he created a soul.

People want to call pets ‘soulless’ creatures, but then can’t explain the bonding, the affection, the way wild animals show love to each other and to humans who have done nothing for them.

Only something with a soul can do that.

1 Like
7

Yes, they have souls, but animals were made with a different purpose than we were.

They don’t serve the Lord. I believe the opportunity for eternal life was given to humanity alone.

8

I believe your dog is with God.

I know the ‘soul’ debate pulls you in, but I think it misses the bigger picture of what God has planned for all creation.

Look up Isaiah 11, lions, lambs, everything restored. Animals are clearly part of that vision.

9

I’m pretty sure the answer is in Psalm 36.

It describes God’s faithfulness reaching to the heavens, his righteousness like the great mountains, and then right there, it says you preserve both people and animals.

Like, why would scripture even mention that if there wasn’t something worth preserving?

4 Likes
10

I’m so sorry about your loss. Losing a dog is really painful. :broken_heart:

I don’t think animals have souls the way we do, but they can still be part of the new creation.

God knows what brings us joy. He knows what we love. I personally believe we will meet our dogs in heaven.