Is Killing During War Still a Sin?

I’ve been wrestling with this question lately, especially given the state of the world.

We’re taught in the Bible that life is sacred, and that killing is wrong, but what about when our nation is under attack, or the forces of good are facing the forces of evil? Can soldiers still go to heaven if they kill someone who is on the other side of a battlefield?

It feels like there’s a parallel between defending our country and fighting against evil forces in a spiritual sense. Just as we’re called to put on the armor of God and resist the devil, sometimes we may need to defend ourselves and others physically. But where do we draw the line between justified protection and unnecessary violence? I’m curious to hear others’ thoughts on reconciling our faith with the harsh realities of war.

13 Likes

Let Us Pray For You

Your prayer matters. Have thousands of Christians around the world offer a prayer on your behalf. Our unique prayer submission will spread your prayer to Churches, Shrines, prayer groups and holy sites around the world.

Submit your prayer here.

I struggle with this too, but I take comfort in knowing that God understands the difficult choices soldiers face and judges the heart behind our actions, not just the actions themselves.

I’ve struggled with this question too, and I don’t think there’s an easy answer.

While I believe God values all life, I also think there may be times when fighting to protect others could be justified, but I’m still wrestling with where exactly to draw that line.

God calls us to love our enemies, but also allows for just defense of the innocent. We must pray for wisdom and seek peace whenever possible. ? Amen.

I think there’s a difference between murder and justified killing in self-defense or protection of others. But it’s a tough line to draw, and I pray for wisdom and guidance for those who have to make these impossible choices in wartime.

You know… I’ve thought about that commandment… “Thou shalt not murder”… It’s not quite the same as “Thou shalt not kill,” is it?.. There’s a difference… especially when it comes to war… When you’re out there… protecting yourself… your comrades… your country… It’s not murder, really… It’s more like… survival… defense… A sad necessity, perhaps… but not the same as taking a life in cold blood… At least… that’s how I’ve come to see it…

Sin isn’t just breaking rules, it’s like a sickness that hurts our souls ?? Even killing in war, while different from murder, can leave deep scars. Just look at how it affected David in the Bible. We need God’s healing touch to overcome these wounds ? Amen!

As a follower of Christ, I’m deeply grateful for God’s gift of peace. May God’s wisdom guide us in these challenging times. Amen!

When I think about spiritual warfare, I’m reminded that God doesn’t just want us to sit back and take it. He equipped us to stand firm against evil. Just like David faced Goliath, we’re called to confront the darkness in this world. It’s not about being aggressive but rather about actively defending what’s good and right.

It’s important to understand the difference between murder and killing. The commandment actually says, “You shall not murder,” not “You shall not kill.” They’re not the same thing. And when Jesus talked about turning the other cheek, He wasn’t addressing murder. It’s easy to misunderstand these teachings if you don’t look at the original context and meaning.

God sees into our hearts beyond what others can know, and maybe He understands those who pick up weapons not because they want to hurt but because they have to shield the innocent from harm.

It’s a weight that presses down on the soul, and I think He’s right beside us as we wrestle with those impossible choices. The moral struggle that comes with protecting life by potentially taking it away is all a jumble of right and wrong and duty and fear, but somehow, I feel His presence in those moments guiding us through the darkness.

It’s like being caught between the Red Sea and Pharaoh’s army—our call to be peacemakers and the harsh reality of a world that sometimes requires us to wield the sword of righteousness. I seek the wisdom of Solomon to navigate these waters, as turbulent as those that threatened to swallow Jonah.