So I keep hearing “give yourself grace” everywhere lately. Especially when someone’s going through it or struggling with something they feel like they should have figured out. I’m not totally sure what that’s supposed to look like in practice. Is it just a nicer way of saying “go easy on yourself”? or is it something more rooted in the Bible?
I ask because I don’t want to confuse extending myself grace with just… excusing patterns I know God is calling me to grow out of if that makes sense… Where’s the line between genuinely resting in God’s kindness toward our weakness and using “grace” as a comfortable word for staying stuck?
You don’t have to pray alone. Have your prayer submitted to the Holy Land as well as churches, monasteries, and prayer groups worldwide who will lift your intentions to God and pray on your behalf.
From the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem to sacred sites across the globe, your prayer will be shared and remembered.
The phrase ‘give yourself grace’ isn’t actually in the Bible, which I think is important to know up front. If you check out every single verse containing the word ‘grace,’ you will find that God never frames this as something we give to ourselves. Grace in scripture is always God-to-us, flowing from Him, not from within. Although I believe that genuine grace always guides you back to God.
John 1:16 says, ‘from his fullness we have all received, grace upon grace.’
And Paul, in nearly every letter, reminds us that grace comes from the Father and the Son.
The issue is the source. I read one of Pastor John Beeson’s pieces on this that makes sense to me: “when we ‘give ourselves grace,’ we’re often just letting ourselves off the hook instead of receiving God’s unmerited favor. We end up coddling sin, excusing unfaithfulness, all while using a word that sounds spiritual, which is not great.”
There is also Titus 2:11-12, which shows both sides: the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation, and it teaches us to say no to ungodliness and to live self-controlled, upright lives.
I think what I’m saying is that it’s great if ‘giving yourself grace’ leads you honestly to the throne of God, but if it pulls you away from conviction, then that’s a red flag. And honestly, most of us recognize the difference even if we don’t want to admit it.
Yeah, these days, many of us say this. It basically means being kind to yourself, forgiving yourself, and not holding yourself to an impossible standard. And there’s truth in that - God genuinely is patient with us through sanctification. Jen Wilkin wrote about reflecting God’s patience and said something like, when we feel discouraged about continuing to give in to sin, we can remind ourselves to be patient because God isn’t finished with us yet. Solid advice.
Although there is a tricky part, Kristin Silva (a biblical counselor) said that when we become the source of our own grace, we might feel like we need grace from ourselves because the law we broke is actually our own. Your own unrealistic standard. When you’re living under the Father’s law, you’re already covered by the righteousness of Christ. His grace handles that. Sometimes ‘give yourself grace’ is just about letting go of something God never asked you to carry in the first place.
I totally get your concern, though, super valid. You don’t wanna catch yourself saying it as an excuse for your sin, rather than something that motivates you to get out of it.
“The kindness of God leads us to repentance, not away from it.” Romans 2:4
I think the confusion comes from how watered down the word ‘grace’ has gotten in everyday talk - people use it for everything now, and it’s lost a lot of its weight.
For us Christians, grace is defined as the freely given, unmerited favor and love of God. It came at the cost of Jesus. Romans 3:23-24 says, “all have sinned and fall short but are justified freely by His grace through the redemption in Christ,” so grace was never a soft concept to begin with.
You’ve also got Titus 2:11-12. The grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation to all people, and it teaches us to say no to ungodliness and worldly passions, to live self-controlled and godly lives. So biblical grace literally trains you.
There is so much to read about grace. If you look at the Greek word for ‘teaches’, it actually carries the meaning of child-training - correction and discipline, not just warm encouragement.
So, to your question about where the line is. Ruth Soukup put it this way: " Grace gives you the ability to try again tomorrow, while excuses allow you to give up. Grace acknowledges the mess and gets back up. Excuses acknowledge the mess and sit down in it."
I also like to point to 2 Corinthians 9:8, which says, “God is able to make all grace abound to you so that you may abound in every good work.” Grace propels us toward good works. And Hebrews 4:16 tells us to come boldly to the throne of grace to find help when we need it most. You go to God for it - it’s not a reason to stay where you are.
So I keep this checklist on my phone for rough days. Am I staying positive, setting realistic goals, being kind to myself about shortcomings, and sharing love? Pretty simple stuff.
Honestly, though, ‘giving yourself grace’ just means not beating yourself up for being human.
Every human heart forgets, every tongue stumbles - and everyone faces trials they didn’t see coming. Listen to the self-compassion episode on The Happiness Lab podcast. I think that’s really what we mean when we talk about grace toward ourselves.
Grace and discipline go together. Hebrews 12:6-11 talks about God’s discipline coming from love, and once that clicked, I stopped seeing them as competing forces. A father who lets his kid run into traffic isn’t being gracious - he’s being negligent.
When we ‘give ourselves grace,’ it shouldn’t mean we stop listening to conviction. It should mean we stop confusing conviction with condemnation. Those two can sound alike if you’re not paying attention.
Conviction says, ‘get up, let’s go, I’m with you.’ Condemnation says, ‘you’re garbage, why even try’
Have you heard of the old proverb, ‘The river that never meets a stone never learns to sing.’ I think about that a lot. Maybe too much. Especially when I catch myself wanting to dodge the hard stuff and slap a ‘grace’ label on it (which, if I’m honest, happens a lot).
Oh, yes, ‘giving yourself grace’ gets thrown around a lot, but here’s the thing, though. Grace in the Bible is an invitation to step into God’s rest and let His power work in you.
When we forgive ourselves and release those burdens, we’re not pretending there’s nothing left to grow in. The grace we give ourselves should look like God’s grace - the kind that calls us toward Christlikeness while still being gentle with our imperfections. Most of us struggle to hold that tension.
The line is drawn when resting in His kindness becomes an excuse to stop moving forward. Simply put, you should still be engaging in spiritual growth.
Honestly, for me, it’s confess without spiraling. Name the sin, receive the forgiveness (really receive it), and then take one small obedient step today.
That’s what ‘giving myself grace’ actually looks like.
I like the idea of recognizing toxic self-talk. It is good to dig into it to find the line between healthy self-compassion and spiritual complacency.
I believe giving yourself grace means treating yourself the way God treats you. With kindness, yes, but also with the expectation that His kindness leads somewhere, transformation and comfort can both be part of it.
Treat yourself like a friend. That’s really what giving yourself grace comes down to.
When someone we love messes up or feels completely overwhelmed, we don’t hesitate. We tell them it’s okay, we say we’ll figure it out together. But when it’s us? We don’t do the same.
I’m not saying we should excuse the patterns God is actively working on in us (that’s a whole different thing). But approaching our own struggles with the same compassion we’d extend to someone we care about - I don’t know, it just seems like it should be more normal than it is.
I get why people get confused about this - they think it means you’re excusing sin. You’re refusing to let toxic self-talk drown out the truth of who you are in Christ.
But think about it. We would never let someone talk to our friends the way we sometimes talk to ourselves. Right? Replacing ‘I’m worthless’ with something like ‘I have value to God’ or ‘I made the best decision I could with what I had’.
That’s what grace actually looks like in practice. Not just a concept.
I strongly believe that the conflict between grace and avoidance truly exists.
When you say you’re worried about using grace as an excuse to stay stuck, is there a specific area where you’ve caught yourself hovering? Or is this more of a theological thing you’re working out in the abstract? (which is also worth doing, honestly)
One thing I want to flag, though - ‘give yourself grace’ can quietly morph into ‘I don’t need anyone else.’ And that’s a problem. In Scripture, grace so often comes through the body of Christ, through accountability, prayer, and sometimes even counseling.
“Grace comforts the convicted, but it also convicts the comfortable.”
If the phrase is making you more isolated or more numb (and those two can look really similar from the inside), It might be time to share it with someone safe, just so you’re not carrying it alone.
I think it simply means being gentle with yourself when you’re struggling. However, the balance is key here. You want to create room for growth without sliding into permissiveness that excuses sin or stalls out spiritual growth.
In Matthew 11:28-30, Jesus promises rest, reminds us that His yoke is easy and His burden is light.
That said, extending grace to yourself should involve acknowledging mistakes, learning from them, and leaning on God’s strength to keep moving forward, not just letting yourself off the hook.
Grace is fuel. Paul literally anticipated this exact misunderstanding two thousand years ago (Romans 6:1), which honestly says a lot about human nature. ‘Shall we go on sinning so that grace may increase?’ And his answer was basically, you’re missing the whole point. Entirely.