Struggles of Dating as a Conservative Christian

Christian Dating
1

Dating as a conservative Christian in today’s world feels like swimming upstream sometimes. Or… all the time really.

Between dating apps that seem to prioritize hookup culture and social circles that are increasingly secular, it’s becoming harder to find someone who shares our values and faith. How are other believers dealing with this?

Sometimes it feels like I’m really being tested here. I’m in my mid-twenties and have noticed that even in traditionally conservative areas, finding like-minded individuals our age is becoming rare. Most people I meet either don’t share my beliefs, are already married, or aren’t interested in a faith-based relationship. Where are all the Christians meeting each other?

I’ve tried church groups and Christian dating apps, but it feels like there’s got to be more options out there that I’m missing. The whole experience has left me wondering if I’m being too particular or if I need to expand my search beyond my local community.

19 Likes
2

Let Us Pray For You

Your prayer matters. Have thousands of Christians around the world offer a prayer on your behalf. Our unique prayer submission will spread your prayer to Churches, Shrines, prayer groups and holy sites around the world.

Submit your prayer here.

3

Something that’s really helped in my circle is being upfront about boundaries from the very beginning. And I do mean the very beginning. It’s best for everyone involved.

I’ve seen relationships flourish into marriage when both people clearly communicate their values before the first date even happens. One couple I know had the woman straight up tell the guy she believed in saving all physical intimacy for marriage, referencing ‘Marriage is honourable in all, and the bed undefiled’ (Hebrews 13:4), and he actually appreciated her clarity.

It quickly weeded out anyone not serious about a faith-centered relationship and attracted someone who shared those same convictions. Maybe being even more direct about your standards early on could help you find someone truly compatible rather than wasting time (yours and theirs) on people who don’t share your values.

4

When young believers approach leadership about fellowship opportunities for singles, there’s often a gentle but firm redirection as if the sacred work of bringing hearts together isn’t part of our calling.

I don’t know why it happens like this, but I keep seeing it.

These same shepherds will speak passionately about the church’s mission to transform society, to be salt and light in a broken world. Yet somehow, the very foundation of that society, godly marriages and families, seems beyond our reach to nurture.

Maybe they just don’t want to deal with it, but this is poor practice.

These same leaders are then genuinely puzzled by empty pews where young adults once sat, wondering why so many remain unmarried. We’re watching a beautiful garden wither while holding the watering can, unsure if we’re meant to use it.

They could help fix this problem so easily.

5

Even friends who’ve drifted from their faith struggle immensely with modern dating. It seems like whether you’re holding firm to your values or exploring secular options, finding a genuine connection is increasingly difficult.

As Proverbs 31:10 says, ‘A wife of noble character who can find?’. Perhaps the rarity makes the eventual discovery all the more precious.

6

Just realized why dating apps feel so wrong for us, they’re built for recreational dating when we’re looking for marriage!

Started being upfront about wanting a relationship that leads to marriage, and wow, it filters out so much noise, but also makes the pool way smaller. Sometimes obedience means a smaller dating pool, but at least it’s filled with people who share the same purpose, amen!

7

The one destined for you shall not arrive according to your timeline, but according to divine appointment.

The years of waiting are not years of waste, but years of preparation. When two souls finally converge at their appointed hour, be it in the third decade or beyond, they shall proclaim with certainty that every moment of solitude was but a necessary prelude to their union.

The match that is meant to be transcends the urgency of youth and reveals itself in the fullness of time. Trust in His plan.

8

Many in our faith communities rush into marriage right out of college without really getting to know their partner deeply; they’re so focused on following the ‘right’ path that they forget Proverbs 19:2 warns, ‘Desire without knowledge is not good, and whoever makes haste with his feet misses his way.’

You also need to discern who is genuinely walking with Christ versus those who just show up on Sundays for appearances; sometimes, the most vocal about their faith are the least authentic in living it out. Sadly.

Maybe the real test isn’t finding someone quickly, but having the patience to find someone who truly shares your heart for God beyond just the surface level.

9

I’ve struggled with this too, building up this perfect image of who my future spouse should be, only to feel disappointed when reality doesn’t match the dream.

It’s genuinely hard right now. Since you mentioned being Catholic, your community might have specific guidance I’m not familiar with, but have you considered joining a youth group? I’ve found it helpful just being around others who share similar values, even if nothing romantic comes from it.

You’re not alone in feeling this way. I really hope you find the clarity and connection you’re looking for.

10

Volunteering at local Christian charities or events helped me. Not only did I meet people who shared my values, but working together on a cause really revealed someone’s true character.

11

I’ve noticed that one of the hardest parts is when you invest deeply in someone who initially seems to share your values, only to discover they view your faith-centered approach as ‘outdated’ or not worth pursuing long term.

The comparison trap hits especially hard when you see younger friends settling into stable relationships while you’re still navigating breakups in your late twenties. Even when we do everything ‘right’, being clear about wanting something serious, putting in effort, staying true to our values, it doesn’t guarantee the other person will meet us there.

I question if the real test isn’t just finding someone who shares our faith, but learning to trust God’s timing even when it feels like everyone else is moving ahead faster.

12

Oh my goodness, maybe God is calling you to a bigger adventure! :slight_smile: Sometimes He uses our desire for love to lead us somewhere new like a big city full of different people and possibilities! More churches, more youth groups, more chances to bump into that special someone He has planned for you. It’s like expanding your fishing net! :slight_smile: Trust Him and take that leap if your heart feels pulled that way!

13

I joined a hobby group hoping to meet people organically but discovered everyone there is either married or 20+ years older than me :sweat_smile: which makes the whole ‘meeting someone through shared interests’ advice feel a bit hollow when you’re in your twenties.

14

I’m in my late twenties and have been navigating these same waters for a while now. So if it helps at all, at least know that you’re not the only one struggling to date as a conservative Christian.

I’ve started going beyond the usual church groups and Christian dating apps. Started attending Christian conferences and retreats when I could. Not only did I meet some amazing people (including a few I’ve stayed in touch with), but it also helped deepen my own faith journey.

There’s something about being in those environments that creates more natural connections, and it’s with like-minded people. Could not suggest this more.

I’ve also really had to lean into the wisdom about being equally yoked. Early on, I tried dating someone who didn’t share my faith, thinking maybe it could work out, but it just highlighted how important spiritual alignment really is. Now I’m much more intentional about seeking relationships that are grounded in shared values.

Because it’s way more important than you might think. Especially as you get older.

Getting more involved in bible study groups and volunteering at church has been huge, too. These settings allow for more organic connections, you’re already working alongside people who share your values, and friendships (and sometimes more) can develop naturally from there.

One practical tip that helped me was broadening my geographic search on dating apps. I know it sounds daunting, but connecting with Christians from nearby cities or towns opened up more possibilities and brought fresh perspectives into my life.

Through all of this, I’ve tried to focus on growing spiritually myself. This season of singleness, while challenging, has actually been a time of incredible personal growth. I’ve learned to trust God’s timing more deeply, which has brought a lot of peace to the process.

Hang in there, I truly believe that staying anchored in faith and community while we navigate this journey prepares us for relationships that will honor God in the most beautiful ways.

15

I totally understand what you’re going through I’ve been there myself. The dating scene as a conservative Christian can feel incredibly isolating at times, especially in our age group.

What’s really helped me is focusing on deepening my relationship with God first. I know it sounds cliche, but honestly, that spiritual foundation has given me so much clarity about what I’m looking for in a partner and helped me stay grounded when the search gets discouraging.

I’ve had to get creative with meeting people, too. I joined a few Bible studies in neighboring towns, and even went on a mission trip last year. You might be surprised how many connections you can make when you expand your circle beyond just your local church. Some of my friends have met their spouses at these kinds of events.

As for the apps yeah, they can be frustrating. I don’t think that’s specific to conservatives, though. I don’t think even the secular people are enjoying the apps now. I tried eHarmony and ChristianMingle, and while there’s definitely a lot of scrolling involved, I’ve actually had some decent conversations with believers from other areas. Far from perfect, but it does open up possibilities you wouldn’t have otherwise.

What I’ve learned the hard way is to really guard against getting involved with someone who doesn’t share our foundational beliefs. I briefly dated someone who was ‘spiritual but not religious’ and it created so much tension, especially when we talked about future stuff like how we’d raise kids. It’s just not worth compromising on that.

The waiting is hard, I get it. But I keep reminding myself that God’s timing rarely matches ours. Some of my friends who are now happily married met their spouses in the most unexpected ways and times through work, volunteering, even at the grocery store! Stay open to possibilities while holding firm to your values. You’re not being too particular you’re being wise about something that really matters.

16

Sometimes I worry I’m being too picky when I notice controlling behaviors or emotional manipulation in Christian guys I’ve dated, but then I think maybe God’s actually protecting me from something worse down the road?