Three days and three nights in the heart of the earth. That’s what Jesus said. What day was Jesus crucified?
Friday.
I used to think it had to be a Wednesday death because of the sign of Jonah, 3 days and 3 nights in the heart of the earth. But the Gospels call the crucifixion day Preparation, and that word is still the normal Greek word for Friday. Luke also says the Sabbath was beginning, so they rushed his body into the tomb before sunset… I still think the heart of the earth saying works fine with a Friday death.
I leaned toward Wednesday myself for a while, since Friday to Sunday morning doesn’t give you three full nights. Then I noticed Luke 24:21, where the disciples say ‘today is the third day’ on Sunday, and first-century Jews counted any part of a day as a whole day.
So, Friday.
Friday. His death counted as day one, Sunday as the third, and “3 days and three nights” reads like an idiom to me, the same way Esther goes to the king “on the third day” after a fast lasting “3 days, night or day”.
The inclusive counting point is what settled it for me too, since Luke 24:21 only really works if Friday counts as the first day.
The fast is ‘three days, night or day’ and it still ends with action ‘on the third day’, so Friday is day one and Sunday is day three.
There’s also 1 Samuel 30:12-13. Do you read that the same way, without needing a full 72 hours?
Yes, 1 Samuel 30:12-13 can be read that way. The Egyptian says he had gone without food or water for three days and 3 nights, then describes being left behind 3 days earlier. It makes a strict 72-hour reading of Jesus’ words seem less necessary to me (more on that here).
The Esther parallel convinced me too, and Harold Hoehner’s Chronological Aspects of the Life of Christ walks through that inclusive day counting helpfully.
Luke 24:21 settled it for me too, though the Esther fast ending on the third day clinched it, but that’s a story for another day.
Friday before sundown is day one. Friday sundown begins day two, Saturday sundown day three, sundown to sundown, and our risen Savior emerges on that third day, just as He promised.
Outside the gates of Jerusalem. That part we know for certain.
The timing narrows down to either Friday April 7th of 30 AD or April 3rd of 33 AD, depending on which calendar reconstruction you follow.
The Friday fits. Everything the Gospels describe about the Preparation day, the rush to get him buried before sunset.
Friday to Sunday morning does satisfy ‘three days and three nights’ under Jewish inclusive reckoning, since any part of a day counts as a full day.
Friday afternoon to Sunday morning is about 36 hours and fits the Jewish way of counting days fine. Jonah’s “three days and three nights” didn’t need a literal 72 hours in the fish’s belly either.
Friday, April 3rd, AD 33, and I agree with most scholars on that. Newton worked it out from astronomy back in the 1700s.
The Egyptian servant in 1 Samuel 30 hadn’t eaten for ‘three days and three nights’ (verse 12) yet he was found on the third day. So the phrase covers parts of three days, and Friday afternoon through Sunday morning counts.
33 AD, April 3rd. Has anyone else landed on that exact date or is it just wishful thinking?
Not wishful thinking, it’s one of the two main scholarly options. Hoehner argues for April 3, AD 33, and Humphreys and Waddington reached the same date in a 1983 Nature paper using astronomy to figure out when Nisan 14 fell on a Friday.
AD 30 is the other contender, mostly depending on how you date the start of Jesus’ ministry from Luke 3:1. Newton leaned toward AD 34.
Friday. Jewish days start at sunset, so burial before dark on Friday already kicks off the first night, then you’ve got all of Saturday plus Sunday dawn.
Nisan 14 on a Friday (both AD 30 and 33, per the astronomers). God’s timing.
John 19:31 calls that Sabbath a ‘high day’ (which could mean a Passover Sabbath, separate from the weekly one). The Greek in Matthew 28:1 is plural, ‘after the Sabbaths’ so I’m wondering if there were two back to back that week.
Anyone looked into that seriously?
