I hope nobody is going to judge me here, but can we talk about sex outside marriage being a sin?
I understand why lust is a sin, but the only way I’ve ever seen this explained is that it was like peeking at your Christmas present before Christmas morning and ruining the surprise. I get why it’s a bad thing, but we wouldn’t call that a sin. So why is sex?
If you are already in love and planning to get married in the future what difference does it really make?
Why is God offended by me having sex? What if you do everything “right” and stay pure, you’re in a loving relationship heading toward marriage, but then you get really sick and die before the wedding ever happens? Did it make more sense to open the gift early or just leave it wrapped forever?
21 Likes
Your Prayer Delivered to the Holy Land
You don’t have to pray alone. Have your prayer submitted to the Holy Land as well as churches, monasteries, and prayer groups worldwide who will lift your intentions to God and pray on your behalf.
From the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem to sacred sites across the globe, your prayer will be shared and remembered.
Submit your prayer here.
Your body doesn’t just belong to you; it belongs to God. You were bought at a price, which fundamentally changes how we honor the Lord with our bodies. We can’t separate our physical lives from our spiritual lives and pretend one doesn’t affect the other.
Our bodies are the temples of the Holy Spirit, not merely a metaphor.
2 Likes
It’s a Covenant. Once you think about it that way, it makes sense. Also, plans do not always go as we want. Giving yourself entirely to someone who isn’t the person you’ll spend forever with carries more emotional and spiritual weight than people want to admit.
There is nothing wrong with seeking love, which is part of being human. Just don’t use someone without care or commitment, it can lead to sin. Sex is like a garden. Rushing to harvest before the soil is ready will not produce the results you probably expect. We are all human, and sometimes we get the timing wrong.
1 Like
Jesus reminds us to look more deeply into our motives and to love and respect each other sincerely. Single people can explore intimacy in ways that truly respect its special and sacred nature. And married couples can sin against each other when sex becomes transactional or demanding. That’s real.
Hebrews 13:4 says, " Let marriage be held in honor among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled."
Sex was created for the covenant relationship between husband and wife. The scripture makes it clear that it affects both body and soul. I believe that’s why many people sense something is ‘off’ even if they can’t quite explain it. It should be treated as sin rather than just bad timing or a matter of preference.
1 Like
That whole ‘what if you die a virgin’ thing is just hedonism. It’s placing physical pleasure as the ultimate value. Sex without real commitment isn’t that meaningful, but the urges themselves aren’t sinful at all. Find a way to channel them into something else.
1 Like
Covenant > Contract thinking.
These two are entirely different, and we have been misusing them. Contract means that if they break their end, you’re free from yours. Pretty straightforward. Convent means you stay faithful even when things get hard, and sex is designed for that level of commitment. The total giving of body, soul, and spirit, with the potential for new life. That’s not a contract-level thing.
Don’t do anything with the other person that, if things don’t work out, you would need to apologize to their future spouse for.
1 Like
Many of us grow up being told sex is dirty, shameful, something to avoid at all costs, and then on the wedding night, we’re just supposed to flip a switch? Suddenly it’s ‘beautiful’.
The purity messaging in many churches causes real damage that affects people well into marriage, sometimes for years afterward.
My pastor said that in ancient Israelite culture, sexual union was the consummation that sealed the marriage covenant. There was no ceremony with a cake and a DJ. The covenant was spoken between families, and then the couple physically came together to seal it, and that was the binding moment.
So ‘why not before marriage’ would have made zero sense to them because the act itself WAS the marriage. Sex is so serious it literally constitutes a covenant before God, whether you intended it to or not.
1 Like
The weight we put on sexual sin has more to do with church culture, not the actual scripture. Is’t it weird that people gossip, are greedy, hold grudges for years, and nobody says a word? But sex before marriage? Suddenly, you’re the cautionary tale in the youth group. In 1 Corinthians 6:18, Paul says ‘against your own body.’ I wonder if we’ve used that one distinction to create a whole separate tier around sexual sin that the rest of the New Testament doesn’t really support.
I wish I knew this as a form of protection, but what I grew up with was **‘don’t do it because God said so.’**I didn’t wait, and I didn’t feel much guilt, but the strange part for me was the bonding. Every time I slept with someone I wasn’t planning to stay with, it felt like ripping tape off skin, and each time it stuck a little less. You don’t notice it happening until you look back.
By the time I met my wife, I had lost something inside me that I couldn’t fully get back. Still can’t.
There’s real science behind this: Oxytocin floods your brain during sex and literally wires you to attach to that person. God knew what He designed into our biology. The command was protective.
1 Like
Does anyone understand the present analogy? Please tell me if I’m missing a deeper meaning here. It seems like an oversimplification to me, and I say that as someone who genuinely wants to understand the logic.
Marriage isn’t just about paperwork. It’s the heartfelt commitment that truly gives the gift meaning. That’s what makes it so special.
You have this incredible gift. You have something that literally holds the power to create new human life and bind two people into ‘one flesh.’ That’s what sex is. God isn’t sitting up there offended by pleasure. He gave you a key that could start a spaceship to explore the universe with your co-pilot forever, and instead, you used it to hotwire random cars for joyrides. The key still works, but you’re missing what it was meant for.
The Church believes that sex serves two main purposes: bringing spouses together and being open to the possibility of new life.
Instead of having the hypothetical thought about dying before the wedding, think about what if the relationship fell apart instead? You would have given that total self-gift to someone who wasn’t actually your permanent co-pilot.
1 Like