I’ve been hearing a lot about The Chosen and part of me wants to check it out. But the creators themselves keep saying it lines up with Scripture… but does it really? Does it stay true to what’s in the Gospels, or does it take a lot of creative liberties that might mess with how I’m learning about Christ? I don’t want to sink hours into something that’ll leave me with a fuzzy or twisted version of the real thing.
13 Likes
The big events and what Jesus says stick pretty close to the Gospels. The backstory is… mostly invented, though.
Scripture says almost nothing about the disciples’ personal lives, so the writers filled in the gaps with stuff like Matthew being on the autism spectrum and Simon’s marriage problems. A lot of the conversations aren’t in the Bible either. It’s historical fiction built around the Gospel accounts, and the creators are honest about that.
My advice is to watch it with your Bible nearby and treat it as a ‘what might it have been like’ story. As long as you keep that distinction clear, I don’t think it’ll give you a twisted picture. I’ve watched all the seasons so far. It got me deeper into the actual Gospels because I kept going back to check what was real, and Jesus started to feel like a real person to me.
1 Like
It’s mostly compatible with the Gospels, but not a substitute for them. The show rearranges chronology and fills in motives and emotional context for scenes that Scripture reports in a few verses. That makes for good TV, though a lot of what you’re watching was added by the writers.
The bigger risk is more subtle.
An actor’s tone and delivery can slowly become the version of Jesus you remember. The scenes of Jesus planning and rehearsing the Sermon on the Mount, for example, came entirely from the writers. Matthew doesn’t say anything about that.
I wouldn’t avoid the show but I’d just read each Gospel on its own before watching the matching episodes, and when the show and the text blur together in your memory, trust the text. The Chosen can illustrate Scripture, but it can’t tell you which of its details actually came from Scripture.
1 Like
I’d say no, it’s not accurate. The creators keep saying it lines up with Scripture, but what they mean is they try not to contradict a verse, which isn’t really the same thing. Plenty of scenes have no basis in the Gospels at all, and the show doesn’t explain that difference very clearly. Maybe 4/10 on that front.
I haven’t come away believing a different gospel, though the Jesus on screen is still the healer and teacher who calls people to follow him, so I’d put the chance of the show twisting the main story at 2 out of 10.
1 Like
Not contradicting a verse is not the same as proclaiming the Word, and every viewer must learn to separate invented scenes from the Gospel.
Exactly. A lot of the invented material is whole character arcs, not just quick scene transitions. Those additions end up feeling just as authoritative and memorable as the actual Gospel material, even when they’re pure speculation.
I used to avoid it because the invented backstories bugged me.
Happened to me with the Jesus Film years ago, and I still hear that actor’s voice every time I read the Beatitudes.